Skip to content

How robotics improved safety and working efficiency in a European premium cancer institute

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Author(s)

Mathilde Roche, Annabelle Angapin, Vincent Blazy, Alexandre Hyvert, Loretta Moriconi, Matteo Federici, Bintou Diawara, Cindy Monnel, Lison Ferreol, Assia Mitha, Hail Aboudagga, Romain Desmaris

Why was it done?

Initially, robot’s operations required prescription re-transcription and chemotherapy relabelling by technicians, leading to manual data entry risks. Robots are known for high-standardised procedures, great repeatability and limited human intervention: adding bidirectional interface enabled improvement of patient safety. Moreover, it shows significant benefits during the compounding process, streamlining pharmacy workflows and ensuring full and paperless traceability.

What was done?

In 2018, our chemotherapy production unit implemented an automated anticancer drugs compounding platform, embedding two APOTECAchemo robots. This aims to meet the increasing patient-specific chemotherapy demands (78,000 preparations/year). In order to minimise human risk and optimise work efficiency, implementation of a bidirectional interface between the robots and the hospital’s Electronic Prescribing Software (EPS) was considered as mandatory, to allow exchange and clinical information retrieval.

How was it done?

In 2020, pharmacists and the IT team defined the interface specifications. Bidirectional information flow was implemented using Health Level Seven (HL7) standards. Interface between EPS and APOTECAmanager was developed and a comparative robot performance analysis was undertaken by evaluating processed drug products, compounded preparation numbers and actual average usage time per day. The staff (i.e. two technicians) remained identical. Data were retrieved from robot’s embedded statistical tool over three months, before (March-May 2020) and after interface implementation (July-September 2020).

What has been achieved?

During these six months, 13,746 preparations were compounded, with 95% infusion bags and 5% elastomeric pumps. Most of these preparations were produced in advance (administration on day+2 or day+3). After interface implementation, the average production raised by 40.5% (from 1,905 to 2,676/month). Interface implementation increased also the average robot operating hours from 3.6 hours/day/robot to 5.8 hours/day/robot (+61.1%). In total, 19 different molecules were compounded, including conventional anticancer drugs and monoclonal antibodies with the number of reconstituted drug vials increasing by 38.1% (from 625 to 863).

What next?

Interface between robots and the EPS was successfully implemented, thereby enabling improved safety and efficiency. Today, syringes and paediatric preparations are still made manually. They require visual and analytical controls to verify their conformity. Mid 2021, a third robot customized for syringes and paediatric preparations will be installed in the compounding unit, to secure these preparations in a more efficient way.

Aflibercept redosification impact in a second-level hospital.

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Author(s)

Javier Alfonso Buendía Moreno, Andrea Portela Sotelo, Lidia Martínez Valdivieso, Jaime Fernandez-Bravo Rodrigo, Gema Marcos Pérez, Dolores Barreda Hernandez

Why was it done?

Aflibercept is an Agent against Vascular Endothelial Growth Factor A (VEGF-A) whose intravitreal indications such as Age-related Macular Degeneration (AMD), Macular Edema (ME), Retinal Vein Occlusion (RVO), have a high economic impact on a Pharmacy Service (PS) budget.

What was done?

A protocol for the redosification of aflibercept intravitreal therapy was implemented by the Commission of Pharmacy and Therapeutics and the Ophthalmology Service, which proposed the redosification of aflibercept vials into sterile syringes for intravitreal use.

How was it done?

Aflibercept 4 mg vials were recompounded by infirmary staff in a horizontal laminar air flow cabinet into syringes with the recommended dosage of 2 mg, hence one vial could approximately be fractionated for the production of 2,5 syringes.
The variables compiled to maintain the trazability of aflibercept through the programmes of computerized clinical history, MambrinoXXI® and electronic prescription, Farmatools®, were: sex, age, indications, number of spent vials and syringes prepared and average number of syringes dispensed per patient. In addition, it was compared the direct estimated cost of the syringes vs. vials to calculate the saving cost.

What has been achieved?

During the year 2019, 305 patients received aflibercept syringes, 172 (56’4%) were male, the average age was 76 years (41-95). Main diagnoses were 145 AMD, 71 ME, 43 diabetic ME and 33 RVO. The total numbers of vials spent were 341, the syringes dispensed were 1174 and the average number of syringes dispensed per patient was 3’85. The total price of one vial was 612’31€, so one redosificated syringe in the PS approximately costs 204’10€. Therefore the use of syringes instead of vials had a potential saving cost of 331.672€ (58’01%) if the vials would have been used. The cost reduction of the intravitreal therapy with aflibercept supposed a saving of 1’58 % of the total expenditure of the PS during 2019.

What next?

The optimization of aflibercept intravitreal therapy is a big cost-effective measure for reducing costs in a PS. It helps to reduce costs in a therapy that is increasing the number of patients each year contributing to the financial sustainability of Health Systems and improves the efficacy of the resources of PS.

Integration of clinical trials management into a safe and fully-automated onco-haematology workflow

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Author(s)

FRANCESCA VAGNONI, ANDREA MARINOZZI, SABRINA GUGLIELMI, CHIARA CAPONE, FRANCESCA MURA, ADRIANA POMPILIO, SIMONE LEONI

Why was it done?

The management of CT requires thorough documentary evidence and well-organized reporting system in compliance with the Good Clinical Practice. Since 2009, the entire onco-haematology workflow is fully-controlled by information technology devices and robotic systems to prevent medication errors and guarantee data integrity. The implementation of APOTECAtrial was aimed to extend the same level of control to CTs.

What was done?

In 2018, a clinical trial (CT) managing system (APOTECAtrial) was integrated into the existing fully-automated workflow of the chemotherapy production unit. APOTECAtrial was developed to enable real-time visualization of CT-related data and trace the processing of investigational (IMP) and non-investigational (NIMP) medical products, such as delivery, assignment, preparation, return, and disposal.

How was it done?

A team of hospital pharmacists, physicians, clinical data managers, and IT specialists analysed the CT workflow and defined the system specifications. Data related to IMP/NIMPs (both for parenteral and oral administration), patients enrolled, and investigator/sponsor affiliations were entered into APOTECAtrial and sorted by CT. The onco-haematology unit’s electronic prescribing system was bidirectionally interfaced with APOTECAtrial. Aseptic preparation of patient-specific injectable therapies was implemented in the supporting device for manual preparation that checks dosage accuracy and identity by photographic and barcode recognition.

What has been achieved?

Since 2018, the overall number of CTs managed was 95. In total, 81 IMPs/NIMPs and 135 patients were entered into the system, while 2740 injectable therapies were prepared, 690 oral medications and 60 pre-filled syringes delivered. The following major objectives were achieved: automated inventory accounting and stock management, reduced manual time-consuming activities (i.e. documentation, transcription), standardized reports in digital not-editable format, and full traceability. In addition, audit trail tool tracks all user edits and changes performed at any stages of the CT management by electronically recording user’s name, date, and time. APOTECAtrial was evaluated by clinical research associates (CRA), clinical research organizations (CRO) and CT sponsors and approved for use in the daily clinical practice.

What next?

The project represents a good example of multidisciplinary collaboration focused on improving the quality of the processes in healthcare settings. The implementation of information technology and automation ensures improved data integrity, safety, and working efficiency, which are key determinants for managing CTs in hospital pharmacies.

Standard Operating Procedures for urgent chemotherapy mixture preparation by non-experienced staff

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Author(s)

Ana Marín-Romero , Inés Monge-Escartín , Esther Carcelero-San Martín , Gisela Riu-Viladoms , Rubén González-García, Jaume Planas-López , Dolores Merino-Calderón , Rodolfo Juncos-Pereira , Carolina Lesta-Domene , Carmen López-Cabezas, Dolors Soy

Why was it done?

Cytostatics are hazardous drugs that must be prepared under safe and sterile conditions. In some life-threatening situations, there is an urgent need to initiate chemotherapy immediately. However, not all hospitals have experienced personnel in safe-handling cytotoxic drugs for 24 hours and 7 days per week.
The objective is to create a consensual protocol to be used when immediate start of chemotherapy is required, and preparation must be done out of working hours of specialized pharmacy staff. A secondary objective is to confirm that non-experienced staff can prepare cytostatics safely and to guarantee their quality by following this protocol.

What was done?

The oncohematology pharmacy team created a visual guide aimed to pharmacy personnel who do not routinely work with intravenous mixture preparations. This guide includes instructions about parenteral cytotoxic drug preparation for chemotherapy regimens that should be immediately initiated.

How was it done?

Urgent regimens were agreed with clinicians. They are: (i) fixed-dose intrapericardial cisplatin, (ii) intravenous carboplatin and etoposide, (iii) intravenous cisplatin and etoposide, (iv) intravenous cyclophoshamide and (v) fixed-dose intravenous daunorubicin. For schemes with different possible doses, fixed banding doses were agreed with clinicians.
A visual guide with images of all the material and preparation steps (including labelling, packaging and protection measures), for each scheme, was developed and attached to a prescription form to be completed by the physician and associated with a material kit that contained personal protective equipment, expendable material, cytostatic vials and serum bags.
The guide was distributed to pharmacy personnel external to preparation area, accompanied by a training session. Selected trained workers were supervised while preparing the mentioned cytostatic drugs in a simulated-base patient scenario.

What has been achieved?

All the cytostatic drugs were prepared correctly reaching a maximum preparation time of 45 minutes since physician’s prescription. The personnel involved maintained all the specified protection measures and reported feeling confident while cytostatic manipulation.
The guide proved to be useful to cover a possible urgent chemotherapy treatment outside the stipulated work schedule.

What next?

Re-training in safe-handling of cytotoxic drugs should be ongoing with regular updates to ensure a proper follow-up of this guide. This work methodology could be extrapolated to other pharmacy areas with similar needs.

SARS-CoV-2 specimen collection kits: maintaining supply through in-house production

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Author(s)

Nikolaus Lindner, Doris Haider

Why was it done?

In Austria, Covid-19 infection rates began to increase in March. At Clinic Favoriten, over 700 patients were treated during the first wave. This resulted in an increasing demand of specimen collection sets. Even though various wholesalers and contractors were contacted, the orders could not be served in a quantitative or timely manner. These circumstances forced the pharmacy to look for alternative solutions.

What was done?

During the first wave of SARS-CoV-2 infections the hospital pharmacy of Clinic Favoriten, Vienna’s specialised Covid-19 center, assembled specimen collection sets manually to meet rising demands, compensate for shortages and secure vital diagnostics supply.

How was it done?

In collaboration with the laboratory department and other clinics of the Vienna health care group appropriate materials with CE-certification were sought to assemble a set that is easy to handle concerning production, distribution and application.
Sterile plastic tubes were filled aseptically with physiologic saline and labelled. Tubes and sterile swabs were then packed in a plastic bag that was sealed with a label providing general instructions for use. Manufacturing protocols as well as batch documentation ensured quality assurance and traceability.
Major obstacles included availability and suitability of the needed materials. Manufacturers of tubes and swabs had to be changed over time, which required close communication with medical wards and the laboratory department.

What has been achieved?

Over a period of seven weeks 2.033 specimen collection sets were assembled. In detail, a total of 20.330 swabs were packed and 10.165 tubes were filled. Through this measure a continuous supply of specimen collection sets, essential for further Covid-19 testing, was secured.
Moreover, the importance of a pharmacy in-house production with the aim of maintaining supply security was acknowledged throughout the entire hospital.

What next?

The initiative has demonstrated that pharmacists play a vital role in handling product shortages and maintaining supply security. In the future, the pharmacy will reinforce to monitor trends even more and will thus be able to balance changing demands and non-availabilities. Like this, the existence of an in-house pharmacy department securing appropriate supply will gain more and more significance. In times of increasing shortages, the initiative serves as a model for other healthcare systems confronted with similar difficulties.

NEW TECHNOLOGIES TO IMPROVE SAFETY IN PREPARATION AND ADMINISTRATION OF INTRAVENOUS ANTINEOPLASTIC DRUGS

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Patient Safety and Quality Assurance

Author(s)

Carlos Aparicio Carreño, Arantxa Gándara Ande, Beatriz Fernández González, Andrea Forneas Sangil, Belén Rodríguez de Castro, Rubén Pampín Sánchez, Cristina Martínez-Múgica Barbosa, Paloma NIeves Terroba Alonso

Why was it done?

To improve safety during preparation and administration of IAD.

What was done?

A new computerized system was established to improve quality control and traceability in preparation and administration of intravenous antineoplastic drug (IAD).

How was it done?

The software currently in use was updated, checking densities of IAD, weights of diluents and consumables. Protocols in pharmacology were adapted and maximum permissible error rates during elaboration were established. The Aseptics Pharmacy Department was equipped with a barcode label printer (BLP), a barcode scanner (BS), a precision scale and an All In One computer for the biological safety cabinet (BSC). The Haematology and Oncology Day Treatment Unit (DTU) was equipped with a BLP (for hospital bracelets) and portable computers with BS.
Regarding elaboration, a qualitative control was performed in the BSC by scanning data matrix or barcodes, recording batches and expiration dates, both of the diluent and antineoplastic agents. A quantitative gravimetric test was also performed using weight measurement of the diluent and devices before and after adding the drug. When the mixture was correctly prepared a label was printed with an identifying barcode.
Administration of the right bag to the right patient was also ensured by scanning barcodes in DTU: A hospital bracelet with a barcode was printed to identify each patient at their arrival to DTU. Prior to administration, double scan confirmation was made, checking patient´s bracelet and treatment (label), by using BS, ensuring that each patient received the drug, at the right dose, on time and by the correct route of administration.

What has been achieved?

All intravenous cancer therapies have been administered with double scan confirmation in DTU since the new system was established (November 2019).
This new way of processing IAD has been completely installed, but not all the antineoplastic treatments have been prepared with quality control.
The whole process has also left a complete computer record of the staff, task performed, time, duration and potential incidents.

What next?

We will gradually implement quality control while processing all intravenous antineoplastic treatments.

COMPARISON OF ENVIRONMENTAL CONTAMINATION WITH CYTOSTATICS IN FOUR AUSTRIAN HOSPITALS AND IMPLEMENTATION OF A STANDARDISED TRAINING ABOUT SAFE HANDLING OF ANTINEOPLASTIC AGENTS ON THE WARD

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Author(s)

Martin Munz, Ewelina Korczowska, Maria Costa, Christine Petter, Shahla Farokhnia, Katharina Kronister, Sandra Dunkler, Thomas Schweiger, Martina Anditsch, Martina Jeske

Why was it done?

Several studies show that contamination with cytostatics is found on various work surfaces in hospitals [e.g., Chauchat L et al. 2018, Hon CY et al. 2014]. Wipe sampling for surface residue of antineoplastic and other hazardous drugs in healthcare settings is currently the method of choice to determine the workplace’s environmental contamination with these drugs [Connor TH et al. 2016].

What was done?

Hospital pharmacists of four Austrian hospitals (Vienna General Hospital, Innsbruck University Hospital, Landesklinikum Horn-Allentsteig, and Landesklinikum Zwettl) differing in size, logistic requirements and production capacity, equipment (but all using Closed System Devices), and involved staff participated in the MASHA (Research about Environmental Contamination by Cytotoxics And Management of Safe Handling Procedures) project of the European Society of Oncology Pharmacy (ESOP).

How was it done?

In the first part of the project, surface contamination by cytostatics was investigated using wipe samples. Subsequently, training materials were developed and used for uniform training of medical staff involved in administering antineoplastic drugs. After the training, a second set of wipe samples of the same surfaces were taken and analyzed.

What has been achieved?

All four hospitals’ results in the first series of measurements were below the reference value given in the project of 0,1ng/cm², indicating “low” contamination. Only a small amount of samples show values between the limit of quantification (LOQ), dependent on the substance and analytical method, and 0,1ng/cm². The same is for the second series of wipe samples after the training. Considering that standards, recommendations or trainings by pharmacists or occupational health professionals has already been in place before this project, the impact of further training for the medical staff could not be quantified by measuring the residues. However, feedback from trained staff was exclusively positive, and our main objective to demonstrate that occupational exposure with cytostatics is low to non-detectable on our wards was achieved.

What next?

We want to encourage more hospitals to get involved in similar projects, and we hope that more powerful analytics will give us more answers for proper handling.

Outpatient administration of dose-adjusted etoposide, prednisone, vincristine, cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin (DA-EPOCH) for Non-Hodgkin lymphoma

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Author(s)

Marianna Rivasi, Gregorio Medici, Lucia Ricchi

Why was it done?

Because of the need to administer DA-EPOCH over a continuous 96-hour period, patients are traditionally hospitalized. Frequently, these admissions may be delayed because of bed shortages. Previous studies have shown that EPOCH-containing regimens can be safely administered in the outpatient setting, thus decreasing inpatient bed use and overall health care costs. Home-based chemotherapy is normally preferred by patients and helps reduce the risk of hospital-acquired infections; furthermore, other aspects such as functional decline and social isolation are minimized. Beginning in August 2019, we introduced an outpatient EPOCH-based chemotherapy model with portable infusion pumps and have already treated 9 patients.

What was done?

DA-EPOCH (etoposide, prednisone, vincristine, cyclophosphamide and doxorubicin) -based chemotherapy is traditionally administered inpatient because of its complex protocol and number of involved medications. These routine admissions are costly, disruptive and isolating to patients. Here we describe our experience transitioning from inpatient to outpatient setting.

How was it done?

We purchased 3 CADD-SOLIS infusion pumps (Smiths Medical) and connected them to the bags containing chemotherapy. One of the main issues we observed in this procedure was the flow disturbances due to the presence of small air bubbles in the pump delivery line so we tried to develop a method aiming to reduce this effect.
We changed the first type of device we used with a new one consisting of an irreversible spike needle-free access to IV bag (BTC, Italia) inserted to the medication port of the bag. Into the spiking port we insert the CADD High-Volume administration set. It is crucial to remove all the air inside the IV bag and make sure there is no extra air injected into the bag when adding medication, finally do not forget to fully prime the tubing.

What has been achieved?

Outpatient EPOCH administration was associated with cost savings of approximately 400.000€ for both chemotherapy costs and hospital day avoidance (45 days). In addition to cost savings, outpatient administration improve patient satisfaction, without any apparent decrement in treatment efficacy.

What next?

Outpatient treatments would lead to changes in how both patients and providers relate to cancer care. Transitioning care out of the hospital and related cost reduction allowed for additional investments in public health.

THE EXPERIENCES OF A UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL MEDICATION PREPARATION UNIT IN COVID-19 PANDEMIC

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Clinical Pharmacy Services

Author(s)

Sinem Şeker Şimşek

Why was it done?

In terms of medication and patient safety, to establish a safe non-cytotoxic medication preparation process, to ensure continuity of well-educated and motivated pharmacy staff are the key elements of pharmacy-based medication preparation units. This work aimed to share our experiences about how to be challenged with the risk in the drug preparation process during the pandemic as a university hospital pharmacy centered non-cytotoxic medication preparation unit.

What was done?

We have taken general precautions recommend by the World Health Organization. However, the protocol we have used to prepare Lopinavir/Ritonavir, Preparation of Hydroxychloroquine sulfate, Favipiravir and Hydroxychloroquine sulfate with Simple Syrup, Preparation of intravenous drugs (Tocilizumab)

How was it done?

The preparation of solid oral dosages, which should be administered to intubated Covid-19 patients through a nasogastric tube, was prepared by the ready to administration team of our pharmacy.
There is no evidence-based data on the bioavailability of these enteric-coated tablets after being crushed and administered to these vulnerable patients. The biggest challenge was lack of the reliable medication information sources. Before starting the Covid-19 medications preparation process, possible risks that could arise if crushed administration of these drugs were evaluated with a multidisciplinary team.

What has been achieved?

We suspended the Lopinavir/Ritonavir with dextrose during the preparation phase. We preferred the lavage syringe for intravenous administration risk elimination through ensuring patient and drug safety by preventing the risk of intravenous administration of the diluted suspended drug we have prepared. However, when we used a 3-way infusion manifold the strain during pushing and easy disconnection of the joints thus the risk of dose loss were the disadvantages.

What next?

The two pillars of dealing with the COVID-19 epidemic, which has affected the whole globally, are the proper preparation of the necessary medicines for treatment and the treatment itself. Drugs were prepared in line with the search for “a practical solution immediately” and the directives of the Ministry of Health and successfully administered to the patients. Our study is noteworthy as it shows that drugs can be prepared not only by the default ways but also by the different methods

Good Manufacturing Practice and chemotherapy preparation: A case study on implementation of a robotic system in a Danish hospital pharmacy.

Pdf

PDF Icon

European Statement

Production and Compounding

Why was it done?

In 2017, the hospital pharmacy has started a project for automated chemotherapy preparation aimed at managing the increasing workload, while ensuring highest level of quality and healthcare workers safety. In Denmark, the authorities expect hospital pharmacy preparation to be GMP compliant. To achieve the best implementation of APOTECAchemo, go-live was preceded by thorough qualification process and followed by robot performance evaluation in a GMP-pharmacy.

What was done?

A robotic system for aseptic preparation of cytotoxic drugs was implemented in the pharmacy-based, Grade C cleanroom compliant with Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP). Specific work organisation allowed the integration of APOTECAchemo into the pharmacy workflow, thereby steadily improving the robot productivity.

How was it done?

A multidisciplinary team defined 228 User Requirements Specification (URS) addressed in the tender and associated to GMP regulations to assess that the technology complied with the intended purpose. APOTECAchemo passed through all qualification stages: design qualification (DQ), factory-acceptance testing (FAT), installation qualification (IQ), site-acceptance testing (SAT), operational qualification (OQ), performance qualification (PQ). The implementation of robot was evaluated in terms of doses prepared, active ingredients processed, and % of the total production compounded. Data were taken from the management software and examined from June 2019 to September 2020.

What has been achieved?

The qualification process was completed in 13 months (from April 2018 to May 2019). APOTECAchemo fulfilled the requirements set in accordance with GMP regulations and went live in May 2019. In the first 15 months of operation, 20,968 doses were prepared with the robot, of which 18,242 infusion bags (87%) and 2,726 elastomeric pumps (13%). The number of active ingredients processed were 21, of which five (5-fluorouracil, calciumfolinate, irinotecan, gemcitabine, carboplatin) covered 58% of the total production. Average production of the robot increased by 39%, from 963 doses/month in 2019 to 1,582 doses/month in 2020. The % of the total production operated by APOTECAchemo rose from 20.9% (2019) to 46.4% (2020).

What next?

APOTECAchemo robot was successfully implemented in a fully GMP-compliant hospital pharmacy, thereby enabling the automation of the preparation process and the reduction of the manual operations. Through the evaluation performed, the hospital pharmacy decided to install a second robotic system to further enhance the automated production.